is it good to be the submissive wife

the harriet tubman statement?
uuuh ok
I respect your opinion. While I am not a Christian, however, I also think even some Christians might appreciate the idea that a fundamentalist reading of the scripture's prescribed gender roles might not be the best model for living in a diverse, modern, society. But obviously everyone has their own opinion about this.

I understand your statement that it isn't meant to mean that the woman should be a slave to men, however, the text was written during a time when that was very much the condition of women, from the cultural standpoint of ultra-Orthodox Semitic culture. The idea of a marriage did not include romantic desire or love and was simply about reproduction and the transfer of property between clans. The head of the household language was necessary because women were barred from being social actors. A woman could not be the head of the household because she held no social status other than as a man's daughter or a man's wife.



Neither. I would find Cupp's politics just as offensive as Jameson's antics. Lol



My property law professor always said something similar about property as the basis of English Common Law and that marriage's importance was driven by its role in the allocation of property, not its religious approval.



I try to keep the power dynamic out of the marriage as much as possible, and hopefully reason drives decisions, not might. I'm not saying that I'm necessarily good at it, it's just what I aspire to. But first I have to have a mate before I can get married anyway, lol.



Didn't some slaves long to go back to their master? Harriet Tubman had to shoot some along the road to freedom. To each his own, I just think that everything we think about gender roles is built on the last 100,000 years of human savagery and that we can do better and I would like to try. Maybe I'm wrong, but I think something better is achievable.

lol....S E cupp is hot and intelligent...JJ is a hot mess. SE brings stuff to the table besides her booty...lol.
 
one thing women always say....they want a man who is decisive. that means they want a leader

I agree with this, but it is just one of the many hats you must wear as a man, husband and father. I'm not the expert in this subject but that's how I see it.
 
I agree with this, but it is just one of the many hats you must wear as a man, husband and father. I'm not the expert in this subject but that's how I see it.

oh i agree....i see where "o" is coming from but at the end of the day a woman is gonna scream..."ve a man".

so u have to define that.
 
I get all that. But God's commands are timeless. And again, the example of the Proverbs 31 woman reflects a strong, enterprising business woman who runs a household with servants and is the wife of an important man. And he and their children praise her. So she does have some social status, in her own right. Women are often spoken of in the Bible. If they and their lives were as insignificant as you suggest, why was it important enough to include them in the Bible which is read and respected by millions as God's word? Also, I disagree with the no love or romance thought. The book of Song of Solomon will put that to rest.

We will not see eye to eye on this because we don't share the same faith/beliefs. But as a Christian, I lived this principle as a wife and it works. (And my husband wasn't even a Christian.) I know other Christian women for whom it works, as well. It works because God blesses it. You may dispute it in theory but you can't dispute personal experience. Lol.

You're quite right about the text. It does speak of a wealthy woman, whose power affords her a role in society. Also true of Solomon as king. Those are the experiences of the elite and we know that those experiences are not and were not universal. The reality is that for the other 99.99% of human society life was much as it is under the Taliban, idealized accounts from the Bible notwithstanding. Thanks for the thought-provoking discussion.

the harriet tubman statement?
uuuh ok

lol....S E cupp is hot and intelligent...JJ is a hot mess. SE brings stuff to the table besides her booty...lol.

Okay, before this gets off the rails, I was using the Harriet Tubman statement to illustrate that many subjugated classes of people have many members who desire the certainty and stability of defined roles even those that oppressed them. I thought an analogy would get the point across faster and with a bit of wit. I failed on both counts.

Not a fan of Cupp, she reminds me of a New Age Ann Coulter, just with a bit of polish.
 
ann coulter? oooh yuck

You're quite right about the text. It does speak of a wealthy woman, whose power affords her a role in society. Also true of Solomon as king. Those are the experiences of the elite and we know that those experiences are not and were not universal. The reality is that for the other 99.99% of human society life was much as it is under the Taliban, idealized accounts from the Bible notwithstanding. Thanks for the thought-provoking discussion.



Okay, before this gets off the rails, I was using the Harriet Tubman statement to illustrate that many subjugated classes of people have many members who desire the certainty and stability of defined roles even those that oppressed them. I thought an analogy would get the point across faster and with a bit of wit. I failed on both counts.

Not a fan of Cupp, she reminds me of a New Age Ann Coulter, just with a bit of polish.
 
This may work for some people, but it's not my cup of tea. I prefer an intellectual and social equal because I look at gender subjugation (even self-imposed) in the same way as racial subjugation. I have also found that women denied equal power in the public/overt sphere, will seek to exercise it covertly/privately, in ways that lead to the use of their "feminine wiles", guilt trips, tears, manipulation, deception, and guile to get their way, and that is a far worse environment to live in than an egalitarian, power-sharing one.

Spit that shit homie
 
Okay, before this gets off the rails, I was using the Harriet Tubman statement to illustrate that many subjugated classes of people have many members who desire the certainty and stability of defined roles even those that oppressed them. I thought an analogy would get the point across faster and with a bit of wit. I failed on both counts.

Remember who ur dealing with here
 
Remember who ur dealing with here

yeah .... grown ass men. now go to your room until we tell u its ok to come out.
maxresdefault.jpg


dont give me any back talk...ill bust your head to the white meat.
 
I get all that. But God's commands are timeless. And again, the example of the Proverbs 31 woman reflects a strong, enterprising business woman who runs a household with servants and is the wife of an important man. And he and their children praise her. So she does have some social status, in her own right. Women are often spoken of in the Bible. If they and their lives were as insignificant as you suggest, why was it important enough to include them in the Bible which is read and respected by millions as God's word? Also, I disagree with the no love or romance thought. The book of Song of Solomon will put that to rest.

We will not see eye to eye on this because we don't share the same faith/beliefs. But as a Christian, I lived this principle as a wife and it works. (And my husband wasn't even a Christian.) I know other Christian women for whom it works, as well. It works because God blesses it. You may dispute it in theory but you can't dispute personal experience. Lol.

What's your opinion on the "equally yoked" doctrine?
 
I get all that. But God's commands are timeless. And again, the example of the Proverbs 31 woman reflects a strong, enterprising business woman who runs a household with servants and is the wife of an important man. And he and their children praise her. So she does have some social status, in her own right. Women are often spoken of in the Bible. If they and their lives were as insignificant as you suggest, why was it important enough to include them in the Bible which is read and respected by millions as God's word? Also, I disagree with the no love or romance thought. The book of Song of Solomon will put that to rest.

We will not see eye to eye on this because we don't share the same faith/beliefs. But as a Christian, I lived this principle as a wife and it works. (And my husband wasn't even a Christian.) I know other Christian women for whom it works, as well. It works because God blesses it. You may dispute it in theory but you can't dispute personal experience. Lol.


It does work. I've known many Christian and non-Christian's that it's worked for.

I think part of the issue is that people get hung up on particulars. While men may want a Proverbs 31 woman, they need to remember that it describes his WIFE. One can't expect a woman to be all that to him prior to marriage nor can he expect it instantly. It's a process that they both grow into. He needs to be the man who is worthy of such, just as she needs to be. A true Proverbs 31 woman is a very powerful woman and many men are not up to what it takes to have that type of relationship, it requires a lot (everything really) from both partners.

Also the whole conversation of perfection....that's a human expectation and pressure, it is not something that God expects, demands, commands, or even wants. I've seen people get really twisted in the idea that they need to be perfect rather than realizing that they were created to be perfectly flawed and to do their very best.
 
TLC Special - Submissive Wives/Marriage

New TLC special looks at submissive wives: ‘I am always available…even if I’m not in the mood'

By Carole Glines
Published May 15, 2015FoxNews.com


Facebook929 Twitter196 Email Print




Now Playing New TLC special looks at ‘Submissive Wives’



Feminists beware: the new TLC special “Submissive Wives’ Guide To Marriage” is sure to stir a hot debate by showing marriages in which the woman caters to her husband’s every need and allows him to be the king of the castle.
And that means he gets plenty of sex, too—even when she’s not in the mood.
On the show, airing this Sunday, two couples, Tim and Tara Furman and Eddie and Autumn Miles, are already in submissive wife marriages while Mark and Kristin Haywood are trying the idea out to save their struggling union.
Tara reveals the first ten years of her marriage weren’t easy and she begged God to change her husband. But she says God told her SHE needed to change.
Cameras capture mom-of-two Tara, now an experienced “submissive wife,” claiming she and Tim have a joyful marriage because she greets him with snacks and affection when he gets home from work--and she also lets him make the major family decisions.
According to Tara, a wife’s “job description is to help her man, serve her man, submit to her man, and sleep with her man.”
In fact, a preview clip from the show reveals Tara hugging her husband and whispering in his ear, “Want to go upstairs for a quickie?”
“It’s wrong to deprive my husband of sex so I am always available…even if I’m not in the mood,” she tells TLC cameras.
North Carolina resident Tara also mentors Kristin, who has upset her husband Mark by lying on the couch instead of doing household chores and won’t sleep in the same bed with him.
Tara bluntly tells Kristin that her 12-year marriage is in trouble because she doesn’t give Mark enough sex.
Tara, the founder of Knowing God Ministries, who gives speeches to women’s groups, advises Kristin, 39, to dress like a “hoochie mama” to please Mark.
Meanwhile, Kristin’s mother-in-law doubts she will be able to follow Tara's advice and become a submissive wife.
"Submissive Wives’ Guide To Marriage” airs Sunday, May 17 on TLC.
 
u have to remember petty never been in a relationship with a woman.....no petty a latex doll doesnt count

Now wait a minute...I didn't say I didn't agree with him. Lol

New TLC special looks at submissive wives: ‘I am always available…even if I’m not in the mood'

By Carole Glines
Published May 15, 2015FoxNews.com


Facebook929 Twitter196 Email Print




Now Playing New TLC special looks at ‘Submissive Wives’



Feminists beware: the new TLC special “Submissive Wives’ Guide To Marriage” is sure to stir a hot debate by showing marriages in which the woman caters to her husband’s every need and allows him to be the king of the castle.
And that means he gets plenty of sex, too—even when she’s not in the mood.
On the show, airing this Sunday, two couples, Tim and Tara Furman and Eddie and Autumn Miles, are already in submissive wife marriages while Mark and Kristin Haywood are trying the idea out to save their struggling union.
Tara reveals the first ten years of her marriage weren’t easy and she begged God to change her husband. But she says God told her SHE needed to change.
Cameras capture mom-of-two Tara, now an experienced “submissive wife,” claiming she and Tim have a joyful marriage because she greets him with snacks and affection when he gets home from work--and she also lets him make the major family decisions.
According to Tara, a wife’s “job description is to help her man, serve her man, submit to her man, and sleep with her man.”
In fact, a preview clip from the show reveals Tara hugging her husband and whispering in his ear, “Want to go upstairs for a quickie?”
“It’s wrong to deprive my husband of sex so I am always available…even if I’m not in the mood,” she tells TLC cameras.
North Carolina resident Tara also mentors Kristin, who has upset her husband Mark by lying on the couch instead of doing household chores and won’t sleep in the same bed with him.
Tara bluntly tells Kristin that her 12-year marriage is in trouble because she doesn’t give Mark enough sex.
Tara, the founder of Knowing God Ministries, who gives speeches to women’s groups, advises Kristin, 39, to dress like a “hoochie mama” to please Mark.
Meanwhile, Kristin’s mother-in-law doubts she will be able to follow Tara's advice and become a submissive wife.
"Submissive Wives’ Guide To Marriage” airs Sunday, May 17 on TLC.

Does anyone ever notice that the submission is always in favor of the man? Same with polygamy. Why doesn't 'God' ever allow polyandry since it's always 'Mama's baby and Papa's maybe'? Anyone ever consider that none of this is the 'word' of a deity and all the word of self-interested men ordering society for their own benefit?
 
Last edited:
Does anyone ever notice that the submission is always in favor of the man? Same with polygamy. Why doesn't 'God' ever allow polyandry since it's always 'Mama's baby and Papa's maybe'? Anyone ever consider that none of this is the 'word' of a deity and all the word of self-interested men ordering society for their own benefit?

I stopped paying attention when people decided to only follow gods 'words' on submission and nothing else

P.s. Goodlove is a twat
 
what do you mean?

as ive been taught it means to be on the same level....think alike. i believe primarily in the religious context
I'm curious on what Ches has to say about this one, but your input is appreciated.
New TLC special looks at submissive wives: ‘I am always available…even if I’m not in the mood'

By Carole Glines
Published May 15, 2015FoxNews.com


Facebook929 Twitter196 Email Print




Now Playing New TLC special looks at ‘Submissive Wives’



Feminists beware: the new TLC special “Submissive Wives’ Guide To Marriage” is sure to stir a hot debate by showing marriages in which the woman caters to her husband’s every need and allows him to be the king of the castle.
And that means he gets plenty of sex, too—even when she’s not in the mood.
On the show, airing this Sunday, two couples, Tim and Tara Furman and Eddie and Autumn Miles, are already in submissive wife marriages while Mark and Kristin Haywood are trying the idea out to save their struggling union.
Tara reveals the first ten years of her marriage weren’t easy and she begged God to change her husband. But she says God told her SHE needed to change.
Cameras capture mom-of-two Tara, now an experienced “submissive wife,” claiming she and Tim have a joyful marriage because she greets him with snacks and affection when he gets home from work--and she also lets him make the major family decisions.
According to Tara, a wife’s “job description is to help her man, serve her man, submit to her man, and sleep with her man.”
In fact, a preview clip from the show reveals Tara hugging her husband and whispering in his ear, “Want to go upstairs for a quickie?”
“It’s wrong to deprive my husband of sex so I am always available…even if I’m not in the mood,” she tells TLC cameras.
North Carolina resident Tara also mentors Kristin, who has upset her husband Mark by lying on the couch instead of doing household chores and won’t sleep in the same bed with him.
Tara bluntly tells Kristin that her 12-year marriage is in trouble because she doesn’t give Mark enough sex.
Tara, the founder of Knowing God Ministries, who gives speeches to women’s groups, advises Kristin, 39, to dress like a “hoochie mama” to please Mark.
Meanwhile, Kristin’s mother-in-law doubts she will be able to follow Tara's advice and become a submissive wife.
"Submissive Wives’ Guide To Marriage” airs Sunday, May 17 on TLC.
This is another subject all together. Create new thread "Abusive husbands and subservient wives"

Now wait a minute...I didn't say I didn't agree with him. Lol



Does anyone ever notice that the submission is always in favor of the man? Same with polygamy. Why doesn't 'God' ever allow polyandry since it's always 'Mama's baby and Papa's maybe'? Anyone ever consider that none of this is the 'word' of a deity and all the word of self-interested men ordering society for their own benefit?

Women are necessary to populate the earth, only the sperm of a few men are needed. In the case of population shortages due to war it would be dumb to draft women to fight because of this reason. Furthermore polyandry doesn't make sense because of the fact that women typically only can have one baby at a time and if she has 4 husbands how is that efficient? Especially when you don't even know whose baby it is. In theory a man is supposed to provide a separate home for each wife and his responsibilities would increase significantly each time he married. It's not for the faint of heart.

I'm not saying it should be a way of life for us in the US, but it has a purpose when certain conditions exist.

Honestly I think a man being in submission to a woman would be more functional than a "equal share of power". Someone has to take charge, it's a responsibility not a privilege.
 
I'm curious on what Ches has to say about this one, but your input is appreciated.
This is another subject all together. Create new thread "Abusive husbands and subservient wives"

Women are necessary to populate the earth, only the sperm of a few men are needed. In the case of population shortages due to war it would be dumb to draft women to fight because of this reason. Furthermore polyandry doesn't make sense because of the fact that women typically only can have one baby at a time and if she has 4 husbands how is that efficient? Especially when you don't even know whose baby it is. In theory a man is supposed to provide a separate home for each wife and his responsibilities would increase significantly each time he married. It's not for the faint of heart.

I'm not saying it should be a way of life for us in the US, but it has a purpose when certain conditions exist.

Honestly I think a man being in submission to a woman would be more functional than a "equal share of power". Someone has to take charge, it's a responsibility not a privilege.

Polygamy is not a response to biology, it's a social system designed to give greater mate access to the powerful/wealthy. In terms of determining actual bloodlines and heritage, polyandry is actually more precise, especially in prehistory, when there were no DNA tests. There is never any doubt about whose womb someone came out of, regardless of questions of paternity. That and the role of ancient women in raising children and transmitting culture is why Jews determine descent by the woman, not the man. I don't agree that the responsibilities of man necessarily increase and that the man is required to provide separate homes for each woman. The ancient division of labor in nearly all societies on the planet was that men engaged in hunting, major construction and warfare and nearly every other socioeconomic activity was done by women, including agriculture, animal husbandry, domestic work, etc.

As for the necessity for few men and many women, I agree wholeheartedly, which makes the preference for male children in most societies even more irrational. I don't think polygamy is a good lifestyle for any society to engage in, but if it is done, I just think it should be done without gender distinction.
 
Back
Top Bottom