7Seven said:MistressB said:7Seven said:MistressB said:Most human collaboration is initiated by those with the desire to see themselves excel. People collaborate because it will benefit themselves (safety in numbers), so collaboration isn't a great example of why humans are altruistic.
Ohhh MissB, collaboration IS the result of the conflict between our instincts and our culture. Collaboration is the power of CONSCIOUS choice. It ensures one is not impelled down instinctual roads of action, but can search out and adopt a new solution to any dilemma. It permits artistic creativity and the opening up of new styles of life, and it even permits progress to human enlightenment. It is not "safety in numbers", but strength in numbers. However, I am not suggesting collaboration is completely "altruistic", it can lead to separateness; I am suggesting collaboration is not completely egoistic.
But you still haven't answered my question!
There wasn't any question except "so we sacrifice passion for commitment", which I already pointed out was a paraphrase of your own statement about arranged marriage.
Particularly speaking, I wanted you to elaborate on this concept.
Fairness demands we add something to the discussion, now, I will like for your to try to prove how the humanity would continue to exist if it weren't for collaboration, and we were completely selfish.
No, what I think you saw was there is no passion in the outset of arranged marriages and equated this to being an passionless existence. Again, you missed my pointed completely.
No, it's not completely egotistic, because the point of it is that, for people with grand ideas, working with other people allows them to achieve THEIR great ideas more readily than if they worked as lone rangers. That makes them neither wholly selfish nor wholly altruistic (unless, as in some extremely rare cases, they have a desire to do such and such an act, make this or that progress to 'benefit mankind'. More rarely I think, though, that the people who make the greatest progress are those who are not readily social animals anyway - they might collaborate but they are those lone genii who conceive of amazing inventions or experiments which turn out to save millions of lives.
But haven't "advances" of civilization helped "mankind?" Truly, how many ideals in history could have been achieved without a collabration!?
Advance for the common good is incidental to the fact of achievement in the most part.
So you're arguing that arranged marriage, being passionless from the outset and disregarding the individual choice of the protaganists, can later 'grow' its own breed of passion? Maybe, but it's not the dream and ideal of romantic love upon which the majority of the west is fed, is it?
Incidentally - because I can't be bothered to find your post on the correct thread - Oxford grads are somehow more intelligent and intelligible than Cambridge grads, is that so? Would that be somehow borne out in the relative status of Oxford and Cambridge in the league tables for the past decade or so?