There are a lot of very successful (in terms of finances) people who ended up with bad credit when the economy crashed.
As with most things, I think you have to take a look at if it's a situational thing or a chronic thing. People have falls in life, sometimes it's beyond their control. I think there is a great deal to be said for those who have had major things happen in life and are able to come out of it in good (or even better) shape. I'd much rather be with a man who can put things back together when something happens (in whatever regard) than someone who has always had things good and doesn't know how to deal with adversity.
I know some who consistently over-spend and yet they have great credit because their family was always bailing them out.
People are getting so picky about every little thing, the lists are getting so long, they aren't going to end up with anyone. Think about it, if most really happy couples would go with all these lists people have now, how many of them would even be together? LOL
Also, I like to play devils advocate a bit. I hear someone saying something like - A man needs to have excellent credit. Ok, he could have great credit but have a lot of debt...is that ok? What if the debt or bad credit is because he has huge medical bills because he has a child with chronic illness? (or some other situation that people don't typically think about when they are being flip about all the things they want in a mate)
Also, how good of credit do they need to have?