I enjoyed it. Hats off to George Lucas for seeing the value in this story and telling it. The script was pretty standard Hollywood, with stock heroes and villains. The racism was made plain, but it wasn't the movie's central theme. The IR love story subplot was done well, without being exploitative. A great cast as well. Cuba Gooding, Jr., Terence Howard, Tristan Wilds, David Oyelowo, Bryan Cranston, Method Man, Andre Royo, Lee Tergesen, the lovely Daniela Ruah, and Gerald McRaney. The aerial dogfights were very well done, courtesy of LucasFilm. Probably one of the highest production value films to have a predominately black cast, ever. One weird thing that stuck out for me, the credits looked like they were from a television show, sort of pasted on the screen. Not important, but given the high quality of the production, it just looked incongruous. Could they have done more? Could they have made the racism more visceral? Could it have been more gory? Sure. But it was great for what it was meant to be: an inspiring Hollywood-style story of good guys who, despite their own troubles, rise above them to face the task at hand and become heroes.
I give it an A.