K
Well-Known Member
Well yeah I agree but it doesn't have to be that strong for me to be happy. I'm a guy my eyes constantly wander any way
ah ok - I get it.
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Well yeah I agree but it doesn't have to be that strong for me to be happy. I'm a guy my eyes constantly wander any way
To be clear, it's not that I wasn't attracted to her, I just never felt "head over heels" about her but I really liked her a lot. I do find her attractive, I just thought if I were to see someone as "the one", she would be someone that gives me "butterflies in my stomach" at some point. That being said, she's an amazing person, we have a lot in common and we get along very well.
Her immediate goals (5 year plan) were settling down and finding a husband while mine were simply dating and continuing school so that I can establish a solid career. She already has her career in full swing with 2 degrees to support it.
Teacher?
Nurse practitioner.
To be clear, it's not that I wasn't attracted to her, I just never felt "head over heels" about her but I really liked her a lot. I do find her attractive, I just thought if I were to see someone as "the one", she would be someone that gives me "butterflies in my stomach" at some point. That being said, she's an amazing person, we have a lot in common and we get along very well. I enjoyed the intimate moments we had behind closed doors and in public.
Her immediate goals (5 year plan) were settling down and finding a husband while mine were simply dating and continuing school so that I can establish a solid career. She already has her career in full swing with 2 degrees to support it.
Scale of 1-10
Where is she?
6-6.5
So I finally had the talk with her and have officially broken up.
Although things ended "well", she was pretty devastated with my sentiments and the hopes of remaining in contact with her on a friendship level isn't likely.
The worst part was that it ended on the exact same day she broke up with her ex last year. I had no idea, she told me afterward.
Nonetheless, I'm not sure if contacting her at this point is a good idea. I don't want to hurt her more by being around or communicating with her any further.
She says "guys and girls can't be friends. It just doesn't work that way." Maybe she's right in regards to us.
and that gut instinct is what I struggled with for so many weeks. I'll admit, as I grew to know her more she became more beautiful to me. I started seeing her so much different than I had initially. It was the toughest thing I struggled with considering she had EVERYTHING else I would ever want in a woman. She felt like the complete package minus my reservations toward her physical looks.
I honestly do feel like we could have been something great but the gut instinct in me was the only reason I took a step back.

No doubt it wasn't easy, but I think you did the right thing. As painful as it was for her to hear (and for you to do), your honesty was the best thing for her (and for you). It's understandable that friendship isn't something she's open to when her feelings for you go much deeper than that. All you can do is respect her feelings about it and keep your distance.
I think it's always best to listen to your gut and be honest with yourself. Even when it isn't telling you what you want to hear, it is telling you what you need to hear. With all of the doubts and questions that kept popping up for you, evidently your instincts were telling you that she wasn't the one for you, which also means you weren't the one for her. To continue the relationship would've been unfair to both of you.
If that level of attraction wasn't there for you, it most likely never would've been. Like KinCA said, it can't be forced. Contrary to what some may think, it's not simply about looks, lust, looking for perfection, or some other shallow reasoning; ultimate attraction and intimacy go much deeper than those things. Besides, if the shallow crap was what you were looking for or if there was no attraction at all, you wouldn't have given the relationship a chance in the first place. When it comes right down to it though, 'lukewarm' is something no one should ever settle for.
If at some point in the future you find yourself feeling nostalgic and looking back on it, don't view your decision with regret. You have to remember that you were doing what was best for both of you at the time.![]()
Excellent Post
No doubt it wasn't easy, but I think you did the right thing. As painful as it was for her to hear (and for you to do), your honesty was the best thing for her (and for you). It's understandable that friendship isn't something she's open to when her feelings for you go much deeper than that. All you can do is respect her feelings about it and keep your distance.
I think it's always best to listen to your gut and be honest with yourself. Even when it isn't telling you what you want to hear, it is telling you what you need to hear. With all of the doubts and questions that kept popping up for you, evidently your instincts were telling you that she wasn't the one for you, which also means you weren't the one for her. To continue the relationship would've been unfair to both of you.
If that level of attraction wasn't there for you, it most likely never would've been. Like KinCA said, it can't be forced. Contrary to what some may think, it's not simply about looks, lust, looking for perfection, or some other shallow reasoning; ultimate attraction and intimacy go much deeper than those things. Besides, if the shallow crap was what you were looking for or if there was no attraction at all, you wouldn't have given the relationship a chance in the first place. When it comes right down to it though, 'lukewarm' is something no one should ever settle for.
If at some point in the future you find yourself feeling nostalgic and looking back on it, don't view your decision with regret. You have to remember that you were doing what was best for both of you at the time.![]()
Let her go. I think it's incredibly selfish to continue a relationship that one isn't fully vested in (especially knowing that she is fully vested). I've spent time trying to make the relationship you described work, it just doesn't end well. You can't change who or what a person is and I think it's horrible to sit around, pretty much wasting her time, just to see if the basic laws of attraction miraculously appear. Dude needs to end it imo.
So I finally had the talk with her and have officially broken up.
Although things ended "well", she was pretty devastated with my sentiments and the hopes of remaining in contact with her on a friendship level isn't likely.
The worst part was that it ended on the exact same day she broke up with her ex last year. I had no idea, she told me afterward.
Nonetheless, I'm not sure if contacting her at this point is a good idea. I don't want to hurt her more by being around or communicating with her any further.
She says "guys and girls can't be friends. It just doesn't work that way." Maybe she's right in regards to us.
You're right, in that my mind was on the fence leaning towards ending things. I actually brought up some of my feelings a few days before it all ended. The sentiments weren't that of a complete break-up, just that I feel that maybe we as a couple have different 5 year goals right now. This was said while hanging out at a downtown rooftop bar. While she did get a bit teary eye-d, it didn't ruin the night and everything was fine--even the next day.wow...that was fast...i think you had your mind made up before you ever posted...you know what is right for you...so here is the thing...in a day or two...maybe even a week you are going to start missing her...second guessing yourself...you will not be doing her any favors by contacting her...contact breeds hope and if you don't intend to follow through you will just end up hurting her more
i hope you find what you are looking for and not wonder some day if she is the one that got away...looks fade...lust fades...life partners through thick and thin are hard to come by...
You're right, in that my mind was on the fence leaning towards ending things. I actually brought up some of my feelings a few days before it all ended. The sentiments weren't that of a complete break-up, just that I feel that maybe we as a couple have different 5 year goals right now. This was said while hanging out at a downtown rooftop bar. While she did get a bit teary eye-d, it didn't ruin the night and everything was fine--even the next day.
It was 2 days (Sunday) after that conversation that we had at the bar when I came over to her place to hang out with her again and sometime into that night she brought up the convo we had Friday night. That was when I had to tell her my true feelings and at that point she decided we should no longer continue seeing each other. I guess you could say it was mutual since I agreed she deserved better and someone who is "ready".
Lastly, yes, I do want to contact her. I have been second guessing myself. I just want to see her one more time. I figured I should wait at least a month or so before I initiate any form of contact but after reading what everyone is saying, it seems as though I should completely stop trying to talk to her in every way. Kind of hard to process that thought, really. I guess that's the best thing to do. It really sucks taking that route.
Lol what does ready even mean?
Ready and open to the idea of being married within the next few years. "Settle down." That's not even something that's on my radar right now.