infiniti said:
Nellie, I can understand your logic. However, the scientists proposal is quite plausible. You said if the baby inherited 100% of the black genes, then she should be darker and have more curly hair.
That statement is somewhat inaccurate because your statement rests on the assumption that "black" consists of a single color gradient and hair texture. When indeed, the possibilities are endless. My brother and mother are much lighter than the darker twin and I know for a fact that there hasn't been any significant racial mixing in my nuclear family (we have family trees and such)
That being said, the genes being considered by the scientist are only the genes responsible for skin tone, hair color and such. The other more relevant genes were indeed inherited from both parents. In the case of mitochondrial DNA (generally inherited from mothers) you can even expect both babies to have their white grandmother's mt. DNA (if their grandmother was a white woman)
I am not saying your hypothesis is invalid. I just wanted to say that what they stated is very possible and is probably the case since geneticists can easily analyze these sort of things! In other words, geneticists are too smart to base their publications on "what the girls look like". I would expect that they have analyzed DNA samples, calculated gene frequencies and performed other sort of standard procedures. It is after all geneticists that proved to the world that race is not really a biological concept.
I would expect that they would have done some analysis as well, but in many cases they are just offering some opinion.
All I was basically saying is that the "black" twin appears
(at least to me) to reflect both of her parents' heritage (the black and white) where the "white" one does not at all.
If you are African American, then the chances are that you have some other heritage somewhere in your lineage and that is why you find so many varying degrees of what they are. And hence why your brother and mother inheirited lighter skin. These things don't happen in a vaccum. The genes must be there. The social structure is what binds a light skinned African American (who may have more white blood than black blood) to a dark skinned Nigerian immigrant. Some of those in your family tree may have had more blood from another ethnicity than black, yet considered themselves 100% black and it went down in history that way.
I too do not accept the concept of "race", at least not in the traditional sense that they lump everyone in the so-called black "race" into the same category, which means that everyone from people like Derek Jeter and Mariah Carey are the same as Manute Bol or Seal.
But on the other hand, I don't deny that groups of people are different. I just don't look at it as broad as tradition does. Science is finding that people are more "extended familes" than the far too broad "races". In other words, two Pigmies are likely to share many of the same characteristics, but they won't find anything that will link them significantly with any other group of people with dark skin that can constitute "race". So it is wrong to lump them into the same category with Dinkas for example.
Looking at things in this manner, there are thousands (perhaps millions) of "races". So as far as I'm concerned, Mariah Carey, Derek Jeter, Seal and Manute Bol are from four different "races".