I copied this from another thread here in this section. This is how I responded. I want to say that it is relevant to DH's statement about choice, and my response about Eunuchs.
Quote:
Originally Posted by TheChosenOne View Post
Changing one's sex isn't much different from dying one's hair or having cosmetic surgery....it's altering one's body from the way it was intended to look.
That is an interesting point, I'll have to think about it a bit, because I am guilty of dying my hair. Would that go for dieting, and exercising also? Maybe it shows I don't like who I am, if I do that?
OK - Thought about it, Changing ones hair color and having cosmetic surgery can be good or bad depending on the motivation behind it, so I will say so can changing ones sexual orientation. Because if I change my hair color to change or hide the essence of who I really am, thus denying my self, I am doing myself a terrible wrong. OR if I do so to deceive others into thinking I am someone, or something completely different than I am, I am doing them a terrible wrong.
In changing ones sex for purely cosmetic reasons, not denying ones real identity, and with no intent to deceive, then I guess I would have to concede it's OK, but in this case he is trying to become a woman so as to appear so to others, and to find himself a male mate. He doesn't say he is homosexual, he doesn't even admit he's male, he calls himself a shemale.
(If this were a hook up site for gay people, I would have kept my mouth shut, and when, and if, I ever want to understand such people more I will go looking for that information, at this point I do not have that much curiosity.)
IMO this is one of the most dangerous forms of lies, because he is actually trying to convince himself, he is not what he is. He may even end up in a relationship, casual or otherwise where a lot of that deception is relevant.
That has not yet happened, as far as I know, so I cannot judge it.
Did you ever stop to think that maybe,
just maybe it would be mentioned at some point in the dating process that she used to be a man?
Don't automatically assume anyone is a liar unless you have proof. Just because she was born with a penis and would prefer a vagina doesn't mean she'll lie about it.
And this isn't a "hook-up site" for anyone. The personals section is, but as the webmaster pointed out on the thread that started all this, that the personals are not to be brought to the board.
This is a message board for conversation. Conversing with someone doesn't constitute having sex with them or having more than a casual conversation, an on top of all that
she put "Shemale" in the freaking title of the thread". So not only is she informed that this is not the place for advertising for a date, but she didn't seem all that mean, and she was upfront about everything from the very beginning. There wasn't any lying on her part, she said nothing wrong (and even rearranged what she'd originally said when she was told about how "slut" isn't exactly a nice word in English), she can't turn this bloody website into a gay hook-up site unless she does so through the personals in which case it has no bearing on this forum or it's members whatsoever...So why does that even come into the equation? "If this were a gay hook-up site" shouldn't even matter, since it's not a hook-up site for anything so it's not like you're suddenly going to have to watch gay porn because she's here. You're not going to turn gay. You may think it's a choice, but even if it is, it's not a
contagious choice. You can't catch our cooties, especially not through the internet.
I'm sorry. I don't want to be rude, but this thought process you've expressed seems a bit irrational to me. I understand it's against your believes for a person to behave as the person in question does in their personal life, but I don't understand how you can disapprove so greatly that you can't even ignore them on a message board. If one gay person's presence bothers you so much as to make you question a website where previously no mention of homosexuality had been stated except when I and one other girl that I know of mentioned being bisexual...then there's something wrong.
One person. After you've been here for a while, seeing that there aren't clandestine gay sex going on behind closed forum doors, you still think that one person is going to suddenly change the very fabric of this website, which is
expressly a heterosexual site in the first place, as stated in the address?!?!. You liked it before...why stop now?
It sounds like the mentality of my hometown, which is old school Baptist, by the way. Bible belt baptist. These people think that the presence of one black person would taint their precious community and everyone in it.
Don't worry, I don't think they're right, either.
In both situations the people are deeply religious, all believing themselves to be perfect Christians. But I was told Christianity is about love, and forgiveness. I was told God loved everyone, and wanted to forgive his children because he knew they were flawed, and he wanted us to be loving enough about our fellow man to forgive him, too. Discrimination isn't loving. Generally it's either seeded in fear, or hatred.
If God would like to forgive us for what we do, if God is so damn benevolent that anything can be forgiven if only you love him in return and be a good person, then why is it so hard to just be in the online presence of someone who wants a different gender? If God would hate her for it, then so be it. But do you really think God wants
you to hate her for it? Why don't you let God figure it out. I think he knows what he thinks better than you.
And as for your explanation about Eunuchs...again, I'm sorry, but I don't use the bible as the last word in everything. It goes down to belief, and while I appreciate the information, we'll just have to agree to having different ideas about the word.