In recent weeks, we've all been witness to yet another installation of a bloody war spectacle that has been going on for centuries ... As blacks and whites leaving America (in relative harmony), we should have some empathy for the plight of the folks who die everyday in the Gaza and West Bank. I thought I'd get you to share your thoughts on my idea for a way out ...
The Jews should (perhaps) just walk away from their land ... albeit with visitation rights to the holy land into perpetuity ... For humanitarian reasons, various Arab regional states and government bodies could compensate them for their land [though this may work out to be pennies on the dollar] I hope I don't offend anyone in this suggestion for it is an innocent one ... geared at cultivating peace in a "holy" land.
Consider the following ... If I lived in a neighborhood wherein no one wanted me ... and I didn't much care for the folks who lived around me .... and I had the means and the power, I would pack up my bags and move out. You might say, "...wait John, but your parents owned the land; it's your land by birthright; your great-grand parents were buried there; etc ...." I would turn around and say ".... OK, but this is not worth a miserable life or a dead life. I'll leave the land, sell off the land perhaps at a deep discount ... and negotiate visitation rights to come and see my "holy" land once a month ...."
Do you guys think that this would be a viable solution ? The Jews could leave the middle east for the some other land in Europe & North America. The truth is that the Jews have much more in common with Americans and Europeans. On a per capita basis, they have the means to make such a transition. As it stands today, there are more Jews outside Israel than there is in Israel.
It has always struck me that the Jews are in a better position to make this decision to move .... They are wealthier per capita and en masse, and they have a more organized governance structure. They leave by the rule-of-law.
When two stalwarts have been at war ad infinitum, one person needs to be the bigger person and pull back ... the recent war in Lebanon was pointless. Everybody knows the Jews had the bigger arsenal. They didn't need to pull an offensive to show magnanimity. In fact, they showed how little they can be --- propped up in part by the tacit approval of Bush.
Sadly, I don't think that the Jews leaving the region will bring peace. Men have always found more clever reasons to kill each other.
I do think that a Jewish exodus from the region will bring the region closer to peace ... Certainly, there are other intractable problems. There is a commercial problem: we loose an ally in a region that is a major source of energy for us. we may possibly introduce a humanitarian calamity of biblical proportions in the war that will no-doubt ensue (Osama traditionalists who want to take the region back to a purer time when Islamists ruled the earth vs. Progressives a la Saudis who believe Islam and money can co-exist).... A far greater problem is where should the Jews go ? I think that there are many parts of the western world that would welcome them ... but where? Finally, history is not on our side. Sierra Leone and Liberia have not turned out well.
Since college, I've maintained a great many close friends from Israel and Palestine. I'm saddened to see these two ancients civilizations not get along .... and the rest of the world just does nothing as the killing continues.
Your thoughts !!!!
JohnMP
The Jews should (perhaps) just walk away from their land ... albeit with visitation rights to the holy land into perpetuity ... For humanitarian reasons, various Arab regional states and government bodies could compensate them for their land [though this may work out to be pennies on the dollar] I hope I don't offend anyone in this suggestion for it is an innocent one ... geared at cultivating peace in a "holy" land.
Consider the following ... If I lived in a neighborhood wherein no one wanted me ... and I didn't much care for the folks who lived around me .... and I had the means and the power, I would pack up my bags and move out. You might say, "...wait John, but your parents owned the land; it's your land by birthright; your great-grand parents were buried there; etc ...." I would turn around and say ".... OK, but this is not worth a miserable life or a dead life. I'll leave the land, sell off the land perhaps at a deep discount ... and negotiate visitation rights to come and see my "holy" land once a month ...."
Do you guys think that this would be a viable solution ? The Jews could leave the middle east for the some other land in Europe & North America. The truth is that the Jews have much more in common with Americans and Europeans. On a per capita basis, they have the means to make such a transition. As it stands today, there are more Jews outside Israel than there is in Israel.
It has always struck me that the Jews are in a better position to make this decision to move .... They are wealthier per capita and en masse, and they have a more organized governance structure. They leave by the rule-of-law.
When two stalwarts have been at war ad infinitum, one person needs to be the bigger person and pull back ... the recent war in Lebanon was pointless. Everybody knows the Jews had the bigger arsenal. They didn't need to pull an offensive to show magnanimity. In fact, they showed how little they can be --- propped up in part by the tacit approval of Bush.
Sadly, I don't think that the Jews leaving the region will bring peace. Men have always found more clever reasons to kill each other.
I do think that a Jewish exodus from the region will bring the region closer to peace ... Certainly, there are other intractable problems. There is a commercial problem: we loose an ally in a region that is a major source of energy for us. we may possibly introduce a humanitarian calamity of biblical proportions in the war that will no-doubt ensue (Osama traditionalists who want to take the region back to a purer time when Islamists ruled the earth vs. Progressives a la Saudis who believe Islam and money can co-exist).... A far greater problem is where should the Jews go ? I think that there are many parts of the western world that would welcome them ... but where? Finally, history is not on our side. Sierra Leone and Liberia have not turned out well.
Since college, I've maintained a great many close friends from Israel and Palestine. I'm saddened to see these two ancients civilizations not get along .... and the rest of the world just does nothing as the killing continues.
Your thoughts !!!!
JohnMP