I wrote this original post over a month ago, when I was stuck between two men. As you can guess, I was in love with and extremely attracted to one guy who is a commitment-phobic jerk. There was also a second guy who absolutely adored me and told me he was in love with me. I didn't like him for superficial reasons and a lot of friends told me if the second guy doesn't feel right, I should cut off all ties to him. I toiled over this decision for some time.
I initially wasn't as sexually attracted to the second guy as the first, but in many ways he was a better fit for me. The first guy had a baby by an ex who hates him and is struggling financially (by his own doing.) The second guy has no children and is more successful in many aspects of his life.
I also had to take a long, hard look at myself. Why was I always latching on to jerks who were beneath me? I have a master's degree, am about to start working on my Dr. yet I've been with guys who've been to prison. I think there was also a messed up part of me that believed I didn't deserve to be loved as completely as this guy does.
Ladies, I've seen the light and I'm here to tell you to look for a man with substance. A guy who has his shit together, because if you're like me the other fools aren't worth your tears. I've chosen the second guy, who is now my #1. I'm happy with him and for the first time in a long time, I feel he is someone with whom I can have a stable relationship and future.
I'm happy for you CS. Glad you figured out what worked for you! Best of luck with your guy.