I didn't say she was advocating dating a bad boy. I just think the way she was defining a "nice guy" was very skewed and plain wrong. She was describing insecure whimps with major issues. That's not a nice guy.
As far as if guys get the message or not.... I think they need to be more concerned about being a good person (the best them they can be) rather than trying to appear to be a certain way to get females. If they are well grounded, with a good sense of themselves and on a good path, they'll find a good woman. But lets face it, many aren't really looking for a good woman, they are looking for surface crap, just like the females they are messing with.
I've heard guys whine about nice guys finishing last. First I think....ok but don't you really want to be the one who finishes last...that would make you the one she chooses for life rather than someone for a moment. The other thing I think is, truly nice guys aren't concerned with any of it because they aren't interested in the so called women who doesn't appreciate who they are.