TreePixie
New Member
I loved Tennant a lot, but I also loved Amy and I don't think Amy/Rory could have happened with the tenth doctor. I don't think he could have watched her be with someone else the way the eleventh doctor did, given that he'd already lost Rose too. The tenth doctor would've ended up alone...maybe that's how they end each doctor's term, once they'd be left alone it's time for a new guy.
I want to see someone a bit different for 12. Mean, moody, darker maybe. 9th, 10th and 11th have all been extremely likeable(9th&11th were growers, imho). Especially given that during the 11th doctor's time, he's become a bit more self aware, it seems time for a bit more introspection? I dunno though, camp and hyper seems to be the theme, but I don't think they can take that much further. A non-human companion would be interesting too, but probably less workable.
Admittedly, I also want to see mean and moody for my own personal gratification, but stillllllll.
'The God Complex' is my favourite of this series, mainly for this quote:
"I took you with me because I was vain. Because I wanted to be adored."
ahh, I died a little inside. If it'd been Tennant delivering those lines, I'd have cried xD
And I guess that's my problem with Matt Smith. He's quite alien, and I'm sorta used to him, but he does not have the depth or the acting chops that David Tennant has (well, seriously, having seen a lot of his other work, damned few actors have his range).
I think Christopher Eccleston could have made 9 quite dark - he's capable of that and didn't always seem terribly fond of humans. I think Tennant could have gone darker if the material had called for it - after all, his clone was capable of genocide.