If You Could Be Reborn, Would You Be Black or White?

7Seven said:
MistressB said:
7Seven said:
This why I continue to be a leper to these conditions, the definition of black and white are but mere meaningless concepts where acceptance and rejection of one is irrelevant. It seems a proposition, which will not admit of much dispute, that all our ideas are nothing but copies of our impressions, or, in other words, that it is impossible for us to think of anything, which we have not antecedently felt, either by our external or internal senses. So I will continue to tear down these concepts because they are not definitive enough

What, like I try to do to your concepts of 'maleness' and 'femaleness' and am laughed at? There is no difference: in each case a set of assumptions is attached to an individual on the basis of physical characteristics.

There is obviously "differences" between 'male' and 'female' that goes beyond mere physical characteristics -- from autonomy and nature to biology. By nature, men are nearly alike; it is only by practice, which they get to be wide apart.

I do dare you to try to prove that 'male' and 'female' have very little "differences."

So all people, of all races, are objectively the same (as in, there are no cultural differences?)

Many gender differences ARE a result of cultural expectation and tradition; of course there are fundamental biological differences between the genders but you know and always have done that I'm not talking about those.
 
I have thought about that before but I love my parents and family so much that I cannot imagine what they would be like as white people LOL. At the same time I do not think he has self hate issues because there is nothing wrong with saying hey, "these are the women I wanna spend the rest of my life with and if being born a different race could help that, then why not?" It is strange how we all feel some sort of undying loyalty to the race we are born to. We never chose what we wanted to be. We just are that race. Why must we choose to being with. This isn't a war with chosen sides or a sports game with two teams. A lot of people wish they were rich, or famous, or a celebrity, or prettier, or skinnier, or bigger, or taller, or smarter, so what is so bad about wishing you were a different race? What do you all think?



There is nothing inherently wrong with it. His point of view might be distasteful to some, but he has a right to make his own choices and form his own opinions concerning his life. Remember though others have the right to give their interpretation of his choices and opinions too. Everyone has a right to their own choices and opinions, but they don't have a right to how other people react to or interpret them. That's why its called a discussion board and not a blog.



IMHO, an open minded person, when confronted with assertions that are in opposition to his own, would at least consider, and counter, the premises before dismissing the conclusion. That facilitates a discussion. A close minded person would dismiss it without consideration for whatever their reasons: fragile ego, laziness, lack of rhetorical skills, etc.



Here is my interpretation of it:



Your friend is black. For the sake of not digressing onto a semantics tangent, I define black as being primarily of African descent with little or no other ethnic influences, or negroid. I define white as being of primarily European descent with little or no other ethnic influences, or caucusoid. He did not choose to be black. His parents who are most likely black chose it for him. It is an inalterable part of his identity, unlike becoming rich or famous or prettier or skinnier. That he does not like the fact that he is black and wants to change it is inarguable.



What is arguable here is whether its fair to interpret his actions as self-hate. To me, the essential evidence is how he judges others that share his identity, i.e. other black people and whether he chooses to suppress that part of his identity. Don't get me wrong. It does not logically follow that a black man that dates white women hates himself. In other words, though some people may swear it is, dating white women is not the sole determining factor in whether you hate yourself or not.

My assertion is:



IF



1

A black man that dates/marries a white women AND



2

would prefer to be white by his own admission AND



3

does everything in his power to consciously and deliberately oppress or suppress those parts of his identity that are black



he THEREFORE



hates himself.



Now each of the premises are necessary and all of them together are sufficient for me to be convinced of self-hate. So to me its not enough to just say if he "acts white", or "talks white", or "listens to white music", he hates himself. We all know those terms are loaded with relative and contextual value judgments, and take on a different meaning depending on who you are talking to. All three conditions must apply.


So here's what's wrong with it IMHO: It's a fact, you can't change your race. No matter what you do. You had no choice in the matter and you never will. So accept reality and move on to more constructive and progressive pursuits.
 
PeyBackTime8818 said:
I once asked one of my black friends of mine this and he had a very interesting answer. He, like me, loves white women and wants to spend his life with one, but he has had alot of trouble getting them to want to be more than friends with him. I asked him what his one wish would be and he said it would be to be reborn white. That way he could have an easier time getting white girls. That was a deep answer and from his soul. I kind of sympathized with him (getting white girls has not been very easy for me either, at least not ones who LOVE me and not just wanna use me sexually or ones that just see me as that token "black friend").

I'm sure you did sympathize with someone like him, not to mention that he's actually your friend as well.


I have thought about that before but I love my parents and family so much that I cannot imagine what they would be like as white people LOL. At the same time I do not think he has self hate issues because there is nothing wrong with saying hey, "these are the women I wanna spend the rest of my life with and if being born a different race could help that, then why not?"

This response proves that he does have self-hate issues. Being white doesn't make it any easier. See if every white man you talk to would confirm that it is 'much easier' to hook up with or be with a white woman because they are white, and you are not. Wanting to be reborn white because of it is self-hatred.


It is strange how we all feel some sort of undying loyalty to the race we are born to. We never chose what we wanted to be. We just are that race. Why must we choose to being with. This isn't a war with chosen sides or a sports game with two teams. A lot of people wish they were rich, or famous, or a celebrity, or prettier, or skinnier, or bigger, or taller, or smarter, so what is so bad about wishing you were a different race? What do you all think?

Why would I wish for something like that???
 
PeyBackTime8818 said:
The reason I asked is that I have heard from plenty of women that it sucks to be a woman. You have to have your period, mood swings, bitchiness, you are so emotionally attached to sex (where as men can have sex with a complete stranger and it be no problem, its just fun for us, like eating or using a toilet, all it is is satisfying a physical urge or need, women need to LOVE the guy and trust him and all that emotional crap). Plus you gotta wear high heels which can be uncomfortable and plus you have to deal with menopause and putting on make up which takes forever and your hair too.

You also have to deal with society's double standards and being groped and looked at and disrespected by men and then there is that whole having a baby thing which I've heard isn't much fun.
I know for sure I wouldn't want to be a woman. I mean men go around calling other weak men "pussies" and "don't be a girl", signifying that the very essence of being a woman means being weak, scared and useless (well maybe they are good for ONE thing, hence the title PUSSIES LOL).

Wait... you mean like, the way you described men versus women in the thread entitled 'SELF CONTROL'?
 
7Seven said:
Why must a man be black or white and how do we characterise it!? My skin!? My Mannerisms!? My physique!?

Who has the right truth to objectively characterise it!?


Are we better of if we fit this niche!? Or do we evolve!?

I find these arguments quite boring honestly, the question implies a credulity; I have to ABSOLUTELY not like something about myself, the politics of skin -- they lack substance and ingenuity, are immaterial and irrelevant, are redundant and cliche. The only thing I would want to change is the nature of politics and the nature of thinking. The ways I see it, in its nature, that is, discussing the politics of skin only gives rise to "chaos theory." And that's how the 'naysayers' want, so you can continue to fit their nice little niche. What about the 'blacks' who just want to "forget" these pretensions and just more the hell on!?

My query to peyback and others like him -- why would you ask yourself this question to begin with!?

Agreed. 100%
 
PeyBackTime8818 said:
I just find it funny how people feel the need to have such fierce loyalty to being one race. I never make ANY decision in my life based off of what other blacks will think of me or "I am black so therefore I MUST decide this or do THIS since this is what other blacks would do". That is stupid. So why should a black person (or white person for that matter) feel bad if they admit that they wish they were born a different race. It does not imply self hate, it is just saying that hey, it has been real hard living my life through the shoes of one race and the experiences I have had have cost me a chance at happiness, it would have been easier maybe to have been another race and be happier. It is not that you hate yourself and do not wanna be yourself. You would still have the same name and voice and personality and body, just a different skin color. Since when does your skin color define who you are???

Oh, please! :roll: Do you even pay attention to your own posts???

"Well, I'm not ashamed to be black, but I would like to be reincarnated as white because life would be easier for me, because I just love white girls, and black people can be close-minded and hypocritical about things, and can't take what they dish out, and even though I've experienced more racism from white people, I still feel that black people are more racist, and have always felt alienated by them, but I don't like it when people who white, try to act black, but if that's how they are, then I love it, but when black people accuse white people of this and that, then they are being hypocritical", BLAH-BLAH-BLAH :P :P, and more BLAH. What is your motherf%*$in' deal, dude? :lol:


Michael Jackson now is still the same man he was two skin shades and two decades ago. He is still the same human being with the same name and interests and thoughts and heart and brain is he not?

His heart and brain warped over years ago, and hasn't been the same since.


Now assume people treated him nicer with his lighter skin than they did before, would it not make sense? Isn't he still the same man still?

Now, assume that you live in la-la land, if you believe that people don't treat him nicer because of it, but you, yourself, know that racism actually exists.


I'm not asking would you wanna be reborn as someone else, just change one thing. One insignificant thing.



Oh, this just screams volumes aboutYOU. Re-read your question for this topic. That is EXACTLY what you were asking us, and since when is black skin 'insignificant'?


If you don't like one pair of clothes, you change. Same thing. The Clothes don't make the man, the man makes the clothes, as they say. Well assume your skin is your clothes.

Well, son-of-a-bitch. The boy knows how to give himself away.


Look at it this way: If you were on a sports team. You were going into a big game that you needed to win. You are on a team called the Blacks and your star quarterback has a broken leg so you are going to have to play with your backup (he sucks) and your defense is the worst in the league and all your wide receivers were arrested last night and are in jail right now. All the backups are in and you are the running back and your ankle is swollen from the last weekend's game. The other team are called the WHITES and are the best in the league and all their starters are healthy. They go on to win the game 120-2. After the game God comes to you and says, I can give you the chance to go back in time and be on the WHITE team...would you do it? Of course you would say yes. So why wouldn't that apply to real life? What is this blind loyalty to one race that you never asked to be apart of to begin with?

Great hypothesis, Malcolm X. Just great. :D


If being reborn white would allow you to get a job you missed out on because the boss hiring was racist, allowed you to not get kicked out of a clothing store when you were only minding your own business, allowed you not to get that speeding ticket from the racist cop, allowed you to be with that GORGEOUS blonde you have been in love with who normally only dates white guys (assuming she loves your personality and everything else but told you she just isn't into black guys), what is wrong with admitting that life would have been easier if things were different?

WOOOOO... :shock: :smt011 You're an awesome dude. Simply AWESOME.


I'm sure most if not all of you feel the same way but I understand your "pride" to be black will prevent you from admitting it, which is sad. What if you were born into a cult that forced you to not have your own thoughts or beliefs and you had no choice but to do what they say? You wouldn't like that would you? Well that is what you are doing if you refuse to speak your own honest opinion from your heart and just say what you "THINK you should say because you are black and therefore must be proud of it". I also know for sure that all of you (who obviously love white women and are on this forum for that purpose) would say yea I wanna be reborn white if EVERY white woman you have asked out rejected you for your being black and you knew there was no WAY you could be happy marrying any woman other than a white woman.

Yes, continue to preach the gospel truth! :smt005

I guess you have a point here though. If I were white, then I would have a much better life, and be considered more important to society as a whole. Then, I will be able to get a job, go anywhere without worrying about anyone disliking me for any reason, get a beautiful white girlfriend, marry her, make her pregnant, and have beautiful white babies, who will also grow up 'privileged' and successful at all of their endeavors, knowing that their 'race' grants them that self-worth, along with the necessary components to accomplish goals, and be seem as human to the world. Yea, I see what you mean there.

That way, I won't have to worry about watching BET, joining the NAACP, having a big ass dick, curly hair, and and big camel nose with booty lips, and being called doo-doo, and stuff. It is a curse, to be black, isn't it?

I guess I'll opt for white as well. :lol:
 
chocoluscious said:
There is nothing inherently wrong with it. His point of view might be distasteful to some, but he has a right to make his own choices and form his own opinions concerning his life. Remember though others have the right to give their interpretation of his choices and opinions too. Everyone has a right to their own choices and opinions, but they don't have a right to how other people react to or interpret them. That's why its called a discussion board and not a blog.



IMHO, an open minded person, when confronted with assertions that are in opposition to his own, would at least consider, and counter, the premises before dismissing the conclusion. That facilitates a discussion. A close minded person would dismiss it without consideration for whatever their reasons: fragile ego, laziness, lack of rhetorical skills, etc.

Hmm....so how does appealing to someone else's convictions whilst holding to your own constitutes one being "open-minded?" Technically speaking, we should always allow for the possibility that someone is correct -- they of course, must provide logical support to their claims, if they can not, then we are justified in dismissing their assertion. Emotional accounts for believing are of course understandable, but if the logic behind that belief is wrong, then, it can not possibly be rational.

Just because one points out the irrational of its logic, doesn't make them "close minded" quite the contrary, they are exercising a skeptical mind, which is quite "open minded." To be clear the way I define open mindness would be: a person who argues from knowledge, not ignorance and can show a conclusion that has highly probable evidence they put forth which can stand to the test of logic and the critique of reasoning.

I only think the problem begins where a person emotional beliefs start to supersede logic and they can not recognise the difference between the two.
 
To answer your question Pey:

If I had the choice to be reborn, I would choose to be the same person. My life as it is, has been fun, education, challenging, yet fulfilling. I possibly can't imagine ( and I really did think about this for a while) what being white could offer me that I possibly can't get by staying the same.

You should know that regardless of who you are, you will have challenges presented to you. White people, like any other group of people have their own set of challenges. A more constructive question would be "how can I better myself". Think about this for a while. Think of everything you think you would gain becoming a white person. Now, do you think there is anyway you could achieve those things without changing yourself. I think it is an African thing, but it is very common in Nigeria, to see a kid wearing rags, eating from the dump talking as though he owns the earth. Yes, on the surface it look as though the kid is on crack. But by believing in himself, that kid has taken the largest step to achieving his/her goals.

While I thank God for not haven grown up eating from dumps (many are not so fortunate), I know that my humble beginnings would not have suggested some of the things I have accomplished to date. Yes, it would have been easier having everything handed to me, but that would be no life (life is about learning about yourself and what better time than when you are under enormous amount of stress)

Today I feel cool, confident and optimistic because I know I have defied odds to be where I am now. That is what gives me my "swagger" (is that how they say it) when I walk. Though I make sure my so called swagger doesn't turn into some sort of abnormality. LOL.

If I were white, I do be a white guy dating a white girl (supposing I still have a preference for white girls). That would be boring. The contrast in skin color and life experience is (well, some of the things) what makes IR so beautiful. I would be disappointed if they were gone! :(
 
MistressB said:
I think one of life's biggest challenges is to come to terms with the way you were born, that nothing can change it, and learn to find your place in the world.

I wouldn't wish to be anyone who I'm not, and I don't think colour should exclusively define the way you are: upbringing and ethnicity is intrinsic to everyone's being, but it is your soul and inner being which counts, unique to everyone.

I agree with you I would not to be anything other than what I am. I have never even entertained a thought like that.
 
I would want to be me, with brown skin like i have now. though rather than black, i would be negro, like I am without the PCers!!

in my youth, i have felt at times that I wish i wasnt black-because of how hard it is sometimes--but as I mature and see so many people who are poor, homeless, disabled, from disfunctional families and uneducated--I THank the Lord, Jesus that HE made me just the way I am. from a well to do family, never wanted or needed anything, my family is one of a kind, amazing and blessed by God to have travelled and lived all over the world. a wonderful history of a family with over a hundred years of education, wealth and property/business owners and most importantly--being called to be a Christian

ME is more than sufficient
 
7Seven said:
Hmm....so how does appealing to someone else's convictions whilst holding to your own constitutes one being "open-minded?" Technically speaking, we should always allow for the possibility that someone is correct -- they of course, must provide logical support to their claims, if they can not, then we are justified in dismissing their assertion. Emotional accounts for believing are of course understandable, but if the logic behind that belief is wrong, then, it can not possibly be rational.

Just because one points out the irrational of its logic, doesn't make them "close minded" quite the contrary, they are exercising a skeptical mind, which is quite "open minded." To be clear the way I define open mindness would be: a person who argues from knowledge, not ignorance and can show a conclusion that has highly probable evidence they put forth which can stand to the test of logic and the critique of reasoning.

I only think the problem begins where a person emotional beliefs start to supersede logic and they can not recognise the difference between the two.

The standard definition is:

o·pen-mind·ed (pn-mndd)
adj.
Having or showing receptiveness to new and different ideas or the opinions of others.
 
chocoluscious said:
7Seven said:
Hmm....so how does appealing to someone else's convictions whilst holding to your own constitutes one being "open-minded?" Technically speaking, we should always allow for the possibility that someone is correct -- they of course, must provide logical support to their claims, if they can not, then we are justified in dismissing their assertion. Emotional accounts for believing are of course understandable, but if the logic behind that belief is wrong, then, it can not possibly be rational.

Just because one points out the irrational of its logic, doesn't make them "close minded" quite the contrary, they are exercising a skeptical mind, which is quite "open minded." To be clear the way I define open mindness would be: a person who argues from knowledge, not ignorance and can show a conclusion that has highly probable evidence they put forth which can stand to the test of logic and the critique of reasoning.

I only think the problem begins where a person emotional beliefs start to supersede logic and they can not recognise the difference between the two.

The standard definition is:

o·pen-mind·ed (pn-mndd)
adj.
Having or showing receptiveness to new and different ideas or the opinions of others.

That definition is extremely vague and still does not describe how you are being open/receptive to new ideas whilst holding on to your own.
 
7Seven said:
chocoluscious said:
7Seven said:
Hmm....so how does appealing to someone else's convictions whilst holding to your own constitutes one being "open-minded?" Technically speaking, we should always allow for the possibility that someone is correct -- they of course, must provide logical support to their claims, if they can not, then we are justified in dismissing their assertion. Emotional accounts for believing are of course understandable, but if the logic behind that belief is wrong, then, it can not possibly be rational.

Just because one points out the irrational of its logic, doesn't make them "close minded" quite the contrary, they are exercising a skeptical mind, which is quite "open minded." To be clear the way I define open mindness would be: a person who argues from knowledge, not ignorance and can show a conclusion that has highly probable evidence they put forth which can stand to the test of logic and the critique of reasoning.

I only think the problem begins where a person emotional beliefs start to supersede logic and they can not recognise the difference between the two.

The standard definition is:

o·pen-mind·ed (pn-mndd)
adj.
Having or showing receptiveness to new and different ideas or the opinions of others.

That definition is extremely vague and still does not describe how you are being open/receptive to new ideas whilst holding on to your own.

Because it's perfectly possible to listen to other people's arguments carefully and with respect whilst having strongly held views of your own. There is more than one 'right' answer to many situations - in fact, no 'right' answers to many morally uncertain issues, depending upon how people's viewpoints stand - and thus it is important to listen to people's views with respect in order to establish a healthy discourse, and acknowledge the grey areas.
 
So...carefully listening with respect constitutes an open minded person. That again is an extremely vague concept. First we must determine what is proper respect in "listening" and how much rambling on emotional concepts can be tolerated before one can logically deduce it to as irrational. Or should we all be mindless sheep for the sake of not hurting someone's feelings!? What we should acknowledge first, is the case on one's beliefs given many situations are emotional accounts.
 
7Seven said:
So...carefully listening with respect constitutes an open minded person. That again is an extremely vague concept. First we must determine what is proper respect in "listening" and how much rambling on emotional concepts can be tolerated before one can logically deduce it to as irrational. Or should we all be mindless sheep for the sake of not hurting someone's feelings!? What we should acknowledge first, is the case on one's beliefs given many situations are emotional accounts.

Of course they are, particularly when they're premised upon religious or other ethical concepts, which are most often heartfelt but unable to be explained using 'logic' or 'reason' - surely the antitheses of 'belief'?
Being truly open minded is to be aware that you don't find those accounts to be reasoned, but to respect that they might be extremely valuable to someone else. I don't think it can be said that to accept other people's ideas of what is 'right' - acceptance of diverse opinion is really what we're talking about - can be said to be acting like a 'sheep', if you do yourself hold views which you feel are rational and reasoned. No-one should ask you to agree with their views, only that you don't dismiss them out of hand.
 
By all those definitions spewing out, I am happy "Closed Minded" and have the truth that I know is correct. Never thought I would be considered closed minded ,especially after going to the most liberal university in the US, but boy am I happy and liberated to know that I nothing happened when I admitted I am closed minded.

If someone has a point, sure I listen, and then I judge the words based on faith and Gods word, what is correct I keep, what is not discard.
 
That definition is extremely vague and still does not describe how you are being open/receptive to new ideas whilst holding on to your own.

That's the definition. You can't redefine words.

So...carefully listening with respect constitutes an open minded person. That again is an extremely vague concept. First we must determine what is proper respect in "listening" and how much rambling on emotional concepts can be tolerated before one can logically deduce it to as irrational. Or should we all be mindless sheep for the sake of not hurting someone's feelings!? What we should acknowledge first, is the case on one's beliefs given many situations are emotional accounts.

No. Listening is not a vague concept. You feel me! Its a a part of being open-minded. Its a way to find the facts in the other persons argument to put through your own deductive reasoning analyses in order to determine whether or not they are, or are not, making sense or they are making an emotional argument. Open-minded is then weighing their argument against your own and honestly throwing out the argument that makes the least sense whether its yours or theirs. Granted, its not an easy for anyone to be. But, ultimately it should get you to a better understanding of the issue at hand.
 
chocoluscious said:
That's the definition. You can't redefine words.

:lol: American vernacular I suspect!? No surprise there! Check your local Oxford dictionary and it should say something like enlightened, undogmatic, etc Again, I repeat, your definition is extremely vague like most American vernacular.

No. Listening is not a vague concept. You feel me! Its a a part of being open-minded. Its a way to find the facts in the other persons argument to put through your own deductive reasoning analyses in order to determine whether or not they are, or are not, making sense or they are making an emotional argument. Open-minded is then weighing their argument against your own and honestly throwing out the argument that makes the least sense whether its yours or theirs. Granted, its not an easy for anyone to be. But, ultimately it should get you to a better understanding of the issue at hand.

I did not say "listening" was a vague concept. I did say "listening with respect" is a extremely vague concept. Ya feel me!?

MistressB said:
Of course they are, particularly when they're premised upon religious or other ethical concepts, which are most often heartfelt but unable to be explained using 'logic' or 'reason' - surely the antitheses of 'belief'?
Being truly open minded is to be aware that you don't find those accounts to be reasoned, but to respect that they might be extremely valuable to someone else. I don't think it can be said that to accept other people's ideas of what is 'right' - acceptance of diverse opinion is really what we're talking about - can be said to be acting like a 'sheep', if you do yourself hold views which you feel are rational and reasoned. No-one should ask you to agree with their views, only that you don't dismiss them out of hand.

Oh.....I see........if I was say your attraction to bm is solely on the basis of his skin and other racial "stereotypes" and called you an racist because of it....would that be something you would accept!? I do not think so....I think you will combat that assertion if it isn't true.

In order for ANY "open mindness" to take place, we must first establish who accounts are psychological investments, sadly, most arguments never get past this stage and end up in one revolving circle -- with people effectively talking about nothing, ending in a "false compromise." Acceptance of diverse opinion derives out of false compromise. The fallacy of False Compromise mimics the dialectical move to a rational synthesis, but does not actually propose a resolution. It leaps to the conclusion that "the truth is in the middle," without proposing where in the middle it is, and without examining what is wrong with either of the two "extremes." In some cases, a False Compromise may even propose a "middle ground" between two views that are mutually exclusive and exhaustive, i.e. where no middle ground exists.
 
7Seven said:
I did not say "listening" was a vague concept. I did say "listening with respect" is a extremely vague concept. Ya feel me!?

Nope. What's the difference :?:

From Oxford Advanced Learner's Dictionary:

open-minded adj. willing to listen to, think about or accept different ideas

Is that English enough for you?

7Seven said:
To be clear the way I define open mindness would be: a person who argues from knowledge, not ignorance and can show a conclusion that has highly probable evidence they put forth which can stand to the test of logic and the critique of reasoning.

How is your definition is even close to Oxford's?
 
Back
Top Bottom