Thump
Well-Known Member
Here's the thing, Captain America like Superman are boy scouts because both characters at their core are symbols of idealism. Both characters play off the idea of a person being at their best and always doing the right thing even if it's seen as not being the most practical thing. Once you start playing Captain America more as soldier rather than "super soldier/super hero" then he becomes just like every other ordinary soldier, just amped up physically. All well and good for the movie take of the character but not the best thing for the comics IMO. That's one of the reasons for the current decline of comics as an industry. Moving the characters away from what made them the characters they are and making them into something that others think they should be.
I see what you saying and your right, he is supposed to be inspirational, but not cheesy. He should be like Batman but without the mental illness.
By that I mean, one of Batman's greats strengths is that the bad guys (and other heroes) know he can kick their asses six ways till Sunday. Captain America should be portrayed exactly like that. His sheer force of will, should be as intimidate as his skills.
The boy scout thing works for Superman because he's pretty much a Greek god in a cape, so he doesn't need any intimidation when he can just fly out of nowhere and pick up a dump-truck or two.